We want you to do for us whatever we ask

It's not a great start to a conversation: redolent with passive aggression, prior collusion and unreal expectation. Not really a conversation starter at all, more a thinly veiled threat that, unless I get my way, toys will soon be spinning their way out of the cot! Not a way of opening up a discussion that many would choose when talking with friends or family.


So it is startling to read in Sunday's passage from Mark's gospel that this is precisely how James and John, the sons of Zebedee, start their conversation with Jesus: "Teacher, we want you to do for us whatever we ask."


I think today we might say that this evidences a real lack of self-awareness: asking the one you name as your teacher to do as they are told. I also suspect that, today. certain personality types would respond by saying: "Not likely", or "On yer bike, sunshine"!


But not Jesus. From my perspective, there is at the heart of Jesus, not just a focus on 'the other', not just compassion for the outcast and downhearted, but genuine curiosity: how many times does he answer a question with a question?


A lot of the training we get (and do) is focussed around asking good questions, about being curious and about wondering out loud. We are often sold this as new wisdom: like we are encouraged to embrace the 'new' wisdom of meditation! But it's not new and I doubt that Jesus invented it either.


Wonder and curiosity have been around for eons and Jesus makes very good use of them: as he does in this passage. To that thinly veiled threat - "Teacher, we want you to do for us whatever we ask." - Jesus wonders out aloud: "What do you want me to do for you?" The wisdom of this question is that it reveals not just the questionable nature of the request but also the underhand manner in which it is posed.


James and John, the sons of Zebedee, were nicknamed by Jesus earlier in Mark's gospel as 'Boanerges' - sons of thunder. I can't help noticing that this brings Macbeth's speech to my mind:  "It is a tale told by an idiot, full of sound and fury, signifying nothing."


Having gently, even lovingly, undermined the presumption of Boanerges, Jesus then does that which they had named in him: he teaches. And what he teaches them, and us, is still as counter-cultural now as it was then; it is still as breath-taking in its expectations of how to behave within society; it is still as easy to understand as ever it was and just as hard to live out. "Those who wish to be great must be a servant; and those who wish to be first must be slave of all".


And, in our current context, that raises all sorts of other questions!


More blog posts
By matthew.buckmaster October 26, 2025
Preached by the Canon Guy Wilkinson
By sam.love October 20, 2025
We are so very excited to be part of The Forsytes , a new TV adaptation of John Galsworthy's beloved novels. Produced for Channel 5 and Masterpiece, the show’s first season - which premieres on Monday 20th October 2025 - was filmed almost entirely in and around Bristol between May and August 2024, with significant scenes filmed within St Mary Redcliffe. You can read more about the production on Bristol 24/7 and watch the series' trailer below. 
By matthew.buckmaster October 19, 2025
Preached by the Canon Dr Stephen Spencer
By sam.love October 17, 2025
On Monday 13th October 2025, members of the SMR staff team visited Bristol Archives to meet Senior Archivist Lucy Bonner and retired archivist Anne Bradley who has been leading the process of transferring archival documents from the church to the Create Centre - home of Bristol Archives - for a number of years. The purpose of the visit was to gather information on best practice for storing, preserving, organizing and transferring documentation to the archives, and to receive advice on how to meet the challenge of archiving in the digital era in which most documents are created and held digitally, rather than printed. This shift in process has had significant implications for the management of archival material, processes for which must now respond to risks associated with the fast pace of technological change and the likely future redundancy of current forms of digital storage technology. During the visit, the team were shown examples of important documents from the church archives, including the original deed for Redcliffe Pipe and the associated pipe lands, dating from around 1190-1200; the founding charter of Queen Elizabeth's Free School of Grammar and Writing from 1571; the C15th deed for one of William Canynges' chantries; and materials relating to the major Victorian restoration of St Mary Redcliffe that took place between 1842 and 1872. The staff team will continue working with Anne and Bristol Archives to embed processes that will ensure current data is preserved for the benefit of future generations.
By matthew.buckmaster October 5, 2025
Preached by the Canon Dr Stephen Spencer
By matthew.buckmaster August 10, 2025
Preached by the Revd Laura Verrall-Kelly, Associate Vicar